Up first is Mary Kay’s liquid eyeliner. When I first put this eyeliner one, it “bled” quite a bit on my upper and lower eyelids. It was fairly easy to apply, but I had to use a Q-tip to remove the extra liner that bled. It did not stay on my eyelids very well. All day, I found myself removing smudges all day. The cost was about average compared to the other eyeliners I tested.
Ease to put on – 3
Durability – 2
Cost – 4
Average rating – 3

Next up is the Marc Jacobs gel eyeliner. This was very easy to apply, but it did not stay on my eyes all day. Again, I was removing eyeliner smudges throughout the day. The cost was about average.
Ease to put on – 4
Durability – 23
Cost – 3
Average rating – 3.3

This eyeliner by Stila was by far the best one I tested! It stayed in place all day without smudging. Plus, it was still in place once my day was over. The cost was about average.
Ease to put on – 5
Durability – 5
Cost – 4
Average rating – 4.7

This eyeliner by Clinique was just average in  my eyeliner test. It was fairly easy to put on but did not dry very quickly and did bleed onto my eyelids during application. It did not stay on very well during the day. The cost was average.
Ease to put on – 4
Durability – 3
Cost – 4
Average rating – 3.7

While the cost of Maybelline Master Precise eyeliner was good, it did not stay place all day. Was fairly easy to apply, but did bleed during application.
Ease to put on – 3
Durability – 1
Cost – 5
Average rating – 3

The Revlon eyeliner was another one that had a great price, but it did not stay on all day. It was fairly easy to apply, but did not last. It was mostly off of my eyes by the end of the day.
Ease to put on – 3
Durability – 1
Cost – 5
Average rating – 3

The Bobbie Brown eyeliner was another great choice! It stayed in place ALL day! The only reason it lost points was that it was not as easy to apply as the others. However, this eyeliner is a great choice!!
Ease to put on – 4
Durability – 5
Cost – 4
Average rating – 4.3